This article puts together a list of the best whiskey cigar combo options on the market, ranking them according to their quality, value, or provenance. Also, each product will receive a score from 1 to 10 to highlight the overall success of the pair. The mellow sweetness of a good cigar makes a great match with a whiskey that warms you from the inside. Through our list, we hope we can help you find the whiskey and cigar that make the perfect pair.
1. Bruichladdich Islay Barley with Romeo y Julieta Short Churchill
This great pair makes for the best whiskey cigar combo for both alcohol and tobacco novices, although aficionados will find a lot to enjoy here as well. Bruichladdich has a smooth mouthfeel and a malty flavor with hints of butterscotch, while the creamy notes of the cigar complements both perfectly. Romeo y Julieta was said to be Winston Churchill’s preferred brand, hence the name this version has received.
2. Glengoyne 18 with Padron 1964 Anniversary Series
This pairing can easily qualify as the best whiskey cigar combo for those beginners who want to try something a bit more adventurous. Glengoyne is aged in sherry casks, enriching the whiskey with oakey undertones and a fruity finish that make a nice contrast to the smoothness of the Padron. This cigar has a nice flavor, but it isn’t overpowering. Therefore, the combo is easy to appreciate by both inexperienced and by regular smokers.
3. Tomintoul 16-Year Single Malt with Joya De Nicaragua Cuatro Cinco Reserva Especial
This combination is best appreciated by those with a sweet tooth, as the smoke brings an interesting balance of dessert-like flavors. The handmade cigars are aged in oak barrels, spreading a delicious vanilla taste, while the tobacco gives hints of chocolate on the finish. On the other end of the combo, Tomintoul is one of the many good-quality whiskeys from Glenlivet. It’s a light and creamy sipper that mellows out the richer flavors of the Nicaraguan cigar.
4. Jack Daniels Single Barrel Select with Dunhill Heritage
This is an intriguing yet classic pairing, with the Dunhill cigar serving up a peppery introduction to the fruity aromatics of the Tennessee whiskey. Both products finish with undertones of caramel and spice, leading to a superb harmony of flavor. Dunhill’s stock of cigarettes might decrease in the near future due to the company’s decision to stop producing them, but there are still more than enough in stock for the time being.
5. Compass Box Peat Monster with Te-Amo World Selection Series Mexican Blend
The salty, herbaceous notes of this medium-intensity smoke will no doubt make you thirsty, and there’s no better way to quench that thirst than with a hearty sip of Compass Box’s earthy, vanilla-tinged whiskey. The spirit underlines all the cigar’s best qualities without overwhelming the flavors, making this the best whiskey cigar combo for those with adventurous tastes.
6. Bulleit 95 Small Batch Rye with Montecristo Artisan Series
Montecristo is one of the most popular cigars in the world, so it had to have a place on our list. Also, it makes a great pair with the newcomer Bulleit 95. The two make for one of the best whiskey cigar combo options, as the rich oakey aroma of the whiskey paves way for Montecristo’s seductive notes of coffee and cream. Therefore, both the beginner and experienced consumers can easily enjoy this great combination.
7. Laphroaig Quarter Cask with Nub Maduro
This is the best whiskey cigar combo for the true connoisseurs, mainly because the Nub Maduro alone has a richness and complexity that might reduce its appeal to anyone who isn’t experienced enough. It’s also considerably spicy, which makes the heavily sweet and peaty Quarter Cask one of the only sips capable of standing up to it. The whole taste experience is, overall, an intoxicating one, but be prepared for a flavor bonanza. If you’re feeling brave, this is the best whiskey cigar combo for you.
This is the perfect place to begin your search for the best whiskey cigar combo. The article brings together the most successful pairings of spicy whiskey and flavored cigars, rating them according to their quality, value, and origin. However, objective taste plays a major role in these situations. If there are any specific pairings that you already enjoy, or if you’d like to weigh in on the offerings listed, feel free to add your comments. We are looking forward to hearing from you.
If you enjoy drinks that are sweeter or milder, you might want to check out this list of the best Italian liquors: